External Damage: The Number 1 Cause of Natural Gas Pipeline Incidents

External Damage: The Number 1 Cause of Natural Gas Pipeline Incidents

I recently came across a report from European Gas Pipeline Incident Data Group (EGIG) titled “Safety Performance Determines The Acceptability of Cross Country Gas Transmission Systems”. The paper presents incident data contributed by six European gas transmission operators over a 30-year period of 1970-2001.

An incident within this failure database implies unintentional release of gas and a release is classified in one of the three categories:

  1. Pinhole crack – diameter of leak is 2-cm or less
  2. Holes -leak diameter greater than 2-cm but less than pipe diameter
  3. Ruptures – diameter of leak is pipeline diameter

According to the report, the main causes for pipeline releases are:

  1. External interference: Activities such as digging, pipling, ground works, excavation, ploughing, slabbing, casing and sleeves may damage the pipeline.
  2. Corrosion: It can be external or internal
  3.  Material failure: Due to construction of material, defect specification
  4. Ground movement: dike break, erosion, flood, landslide, mining

Relative percentage of incidents based on incident cause is presented in table below – 50% of the pipeline releases appear to be caused by external interference. Furthermore, when a pipeline is damaged by external interference there is a 75% chance that it will lead to a hole or a guillotine rupture.

Initiating Events Leading to Pipeline Incidents

Initiating Event %
External interference 50
Construction defect 17
Corossion 15
Ground movement 7
Hot-tap error 5
Others 6

Of the corrosion incidents reported, 79% are caused by external corrosion. Furthermore, 74% of the external corrosion incidents were due to pitting.

One Response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Natural Gas Pipelines
Dr. Saraf

New Pipeline Safety Bill

California senators introduced a new bill on pipeline safety – The Strengthening Pipeline Safety and Enforcement Act of 2011. A few key elements in the proposed legislature

Read More »
biofuel
Biofuels
Dr. Saraf

Fire at a Biodiesel Facility

A month ago, I wrote about fire in a biodiesel facility – the last one for 2010. http://risk-safety.com/risksafetynewsite/another-biodiesel-firehopfully-the-last-one-for-2010/ Four days into 2011, a fire was reported

Read More »